Best Training Collar for Stubborn Dogs: 5 Top Picks For Pet

Every product is carefully reviewed by our experts. As an Amazon Associate we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you from qualifying purchases. 

A stubborn dog training collar, such as the best training collar for stubborn dogs, might help you teach a new dog or a resistant pet. Unfortunately, lack of training and socializing causes most dogs to develop problem habits. Using the best training collar for stubborn dogs is one of the most effective methods to curb bad behavior, but it requires time and effort. Repeated positive reinforcement with the best training collar for stubborn dogs will make your pet happy and well-behaved.

Unfortunately, inappropriate usage of these collars, including the best training collar for stubborn dogs, may injure and pain your dog. Before using any of these gadgets, consult your vet or a trained trainer to ensure that you are using the best training collar for stubborn dogs correctly. Misuse may induce hostility and teach harmful habits. Are you struggling to control your stubborn dog’s behavior? We’ve included the top obstinate dog training collars for teaching a new best buddy or an old dog a new trick, with a focus on the best training collar for stubborn dogs.

A training collar could be the solution you’re looking for. With a wide range of options available, it’s crucial to choose the best training collar for stubborn dogs that suits both your pet’s needs and your training goals. In this comprehensive buying guide, we’ll walk you through the key factors to consider when making your decision.

The criteria we used to choose the most effective training collars for obstinate dogs

You may be astonished to learn how many distinct models of dog training collars are now available on the market. However, we were able to swiftly narrow down the list by combining our own experience with reading reviews and speaking with professionals in the field of dog training. As a direct consequence of this, well-known companies have established themselves as industry leaders in the field of dog training. We have made available to you the most effective training collars so that you and your dog may have a long and happy life together, free from stubbornness.

How to choose training collar for stubborn dogs

1. Training Methods

  • Prioritize humane training methods and consult with a professional dog trainer if needed. Avoid using training collars on puppies under six months old.

2. Consult Your Vet

  • Before using a training collar, consult your veterinarian to ensure it’s suitable for your dog’s health and behavior issues.

3. Training Consistency

  • Be consistent in your training approach and use positive reinforcement alongside the collar to reward good behavior.

4. Read Reviews

  • Read customer reviews and seek recommendations from experienced dog owners to get insights into the collar’s effectiveness.

5. Training Collar Etiquette

  • Educate yourself on proper training collar usage to avoid causing harm or stress to your dog.

Understanding Training Collars

Training collars come in various types, each designed for specific training needs. Before making a purchase, it’s essential to understand the different options available:

Type of Training Collar

There are several types of training collars available:

  • Static (Shock) Collars: Deliver a mild static correction.
  • Vibration Collars: Emit a vibrating sensation.
  • Citronella Collars: Release a burst of citronella spray.
  • Ultrasonic Collars: Emit a high-pitched sound only dogs can hear.

Choose the type that aligns with your dog’s temperament and your training preferences. Stubborn dogs may require a more assertive option but always prioritize humane training methods.

Static Collars (E-Collars)

Static collars emit a mild electric stimulation when activated by the owner. They are often adjustable, allowing you to set the intensity level according to your dog’s sensitivity. These collars can be highly effective for stubborn dogs, but they should be used with caution and under the guidance of a professional trainer.


  • Effectiveness: Static collars can be highly effective for stubborn dogs, especially when used correctly.
  • Adjustable Intensity: Most static collars offer adjustable intensity levels, allowing you to tailor the stimulation to your dog’s sensitivity.
  • Quick Results: They often yield faster results compared to other types of collars.


  • Potential for Harm: If used incorrectly, static collars can cause physical or psychological harm to the dog.
  • Professional Guidance: They require proper training and guidance from a professional to ensure safe and effective use.

Vibration Collars

Vibration collars provide a gentle vibrating sensation that distracts or gets your dog’s attention. They are less intense than static collars and are suitable for mild training needs.


  • Non-Painful: Vibration collars provide a non-painful stimulation that many dogs find less aversive.
  • Effective for Mild Issues: They are suitable for mild training needs and can be effective for some stubborn dogs.
  • Safe: Vibration collars are generally safe and unlikely to cause harm.


  • Limited Effectiveness: They may not be as effective for more serious behavior issues or highly stubborn dogs.
  • Varied Sensitivity: The effectiveness of vibration collars can vary from one dog to another.
  • Battery Dependency: They rely on batteries, so you’ll need to ensure the collar is adequately charged.

Citronella Collars

Citronella collars release a burst of citronella spray when triggered. Dogs dislike the smell, which discourages barking or other unwanted behaviors. These collars are non-painful and safe.


  • Safe and Humane: Citronella collars offer a safe and humane way to deter unwanted behaviors.
  • Environmentally Friendly: The citronella spray is environmentally friendly and non-toxic.
  • Effective for Barking: They are particularly effective for curbing excessive barking.


  • Limited Applications: Citronella collars may not work for all training needs and are primarily designed for addressing barking.
  • Refill Requirements: You’ll need to regularly refill the citronella spray, which can be an ongoing cost.

Ultrasonic Collars

Ultrasonic collars emit a high-pitched sound that is unpleasant to dogs but inaudible to humans. They are primarily used to stop excessive barking.


  • Non-Invasive: Ultrasonic collars are non-invasive and do not require physical contact with the dog.
  • Safe: They are generally safe and do not pose any physical harm to the dog.
  • Useful for Specific Behaviors: Ultrasonic collars can be effective for curbing excessive barking or specific behavioral issues.


  • Limited Range: They have a limited range, so they may not be effective in large open spaces.
  • Effectiveness Varies: Some dogs may become desensitized to the ultrasonic sound over time.

Incorporating these advantages and disadvantages into your buying guide will help readers make informed decisions when choosing the best training collar for their stubborn dogs.

Our Top Picks

The Best Training Collar for Stubborn Dogs: Reviews & Recommendations

1. Best for hunting dogs: Garmin Sport PRO Bundle


Key Features:

  • Multi-Dog Training: Simultaneously train up to 3 dogs with ease.
  • Tone and Vibration: Offers adjustable tone and vibration modes for effective communication.
  • Handheld Convenience: Ergonomically designed for one-handed operation, ensuring comfort and control.
  • Long Battery Life: Enjoy extended training sessions with impressive battery life.
  • Durable Build: Built to withstand outdoor conditions and active dogs.


  • Efficient multi-dog training.
  • Precise tone and vibration controls.
  • User-friendly one-handed operation.
  • Sturdy construction for durability.
  • Long-lasting battery for extended use.


  • Higher price point.
  • Some dogs may not respond well to tone/vibration alone.

Customer Opinions: I have an overprotective reactive female doberman and she was unworkable without attacking me or the other dogs when she wanted to eat someone. Night and day difference. Instead of snapping she snaps out of it and can focus on what she wants without having to react to her impulsive behavior. Good tool! I do not suggest this for nonhunters or non-psychologically educated adults. See More

In conclusion, the Garmin Sport PRO Bundle is a top-tier dog training solution with unmatched convenience and functionality. While it may be pricier, its features and performance make it a worthwhile investment for serious trainers and pet owners.

2. Best overall: SportDOG Brand FieldTrainer 425X Remote Trainer

81FZg2ZQthL. AC SX300

Main Features:

  • 500-yard range: Allows you to train your dog effectively even at a distance.
  • Three training modes: Offers shock, vibrate, and tone options to suit your dog’s needs.
  • Rechargeable battery: No need to constantly buy replacement batteries.
  • Waterproof design: Ensures durability in various weather conditions.
  • Expandable to control multiple dogs: Ideal for multi-pet households.


  • Effective training options for various behaviors.
  • Long-range coverage for outdoor training.
  • Durable and waterproof, suitable for active dogs.
  • Rechargeable battery saves on ongoing costs.
  • Expandable for multi-dog households.


  • Some dogs may find the shock mode uncomfortable.
  • Initial setup and calibration may take time.

Customer Opinions: ‘Worth the money!’ Speaks for itself, it’s def waterproof and dirtproof, have been to the ocean and in mud with my corgi for off-leash fun. This e-collar has been through so much and it still works!!. See More

Conclusion: The SportDOG Brand FieldTrainer 425X Remote Trainer is a valuable tool for dog owners looking to train their pets effectively. With its versatile training modes, long-range coverage, and durability, it’s a reliable choice for obedience training. However, be cautious when using the shock mode and take time for proper setup. Overall, it’s a beneficial investment for dog owners seeking an efficient remote training collar.

3. Best for barking: PetSafe Remote Training Collar – 300 Yard (900 FT) 

71zRIfdp+pL. AC SX300

Key Features:

  • Wide Range: The 300-yard range ensures effective training even in large outdoor spaces.
  • Customizable Training: Choose from Tone, Vibration, or Static Stimulation modes for tailored training.
  • Collar Fits All: Designed for medium and large dogs, accommodating a wide range of breeds.
  • User-Friendly: Easy-to-use remote control simplifies training for pet owners.
  • Durable Design: Built to withstand outdoor conditions for long-lasting use.


  • Effective Training: Versatile modes suit various training requirements.
  • Large Range: Ample distance for off-leash training.
  • Durability: Designed to withstand rugged outdoor use.


  • May not be suitable for very small dogs.
  • Some dogs may be sensitive to static stimulation.

Customer Opinions: It was great but after 5 months the remote doesn’t work. It was not helpful to go to customer service. Then called Pet Safe. It is under warranty. They will replace. See More

Conclusion: The PetSafe Remote Training Collar is a versatile and durable training tool suitable for medium to large dogs. Its customizable modes and impressive range make it an excellent choice for off-leash training. However, consider your dog’s size and sensitivity when using static stimulation. Overall, it’s a valuable addition to any pet owner’s training toolkit.

4. Best for aggressive dogs: PetSpy P620 Dog Training Shock Collar

81W3kT3XBES. AC SX300

Main Features:

PetSpy P620 Dog Training Collar promotes good manners. It is unique in helping experienced dog trainers and first-time pet owners teach their pets in days. Dog training is about educating humans about the dog as well as the dog. By knowing how dogs think, humans can teach them better. Our free dog training e-book demonstrates proper technique.

  • Three humane training modes with 16 adjustable levels
  • Both the receiver and remote are rechargeable and 100% waterproof
  • Easy-to-distinguish buttons can be operated blindly by touch.
  • Quickly and effectively train your dog from up to 650 yards away.
  • Helps correct barking, wandering off, aggressive leash pulling, approaching strangers, and more
  • Safe for all breeds and sizes, from 10 to 140 lbs


  • Versatile training modes for different temperaments.
  • Long-lasting and waterproof design.
  • Adjustable intensity for safe and effective training.
  • Impressive remote range.
  • Suitable for a wide range of dog sizes.


  • May not be suitable for dogs under 10 lbs.
  • Some dogs may be sensitive to static stimulation.

Customer Opinions: My husband borrowed our grandson’s dog trainer…then decided it worked so well, he would get his own. Our smooth-coat border collie is behaving so much better. She still has a puppy brain, yet she is catching onto what manners are. Giving her time to mature, but the collar trainer is a perfect helper for now. See More

Conclusion: The PetSpy P620 Dog Training Shock Collar offers a versatile and effective solution for training dogs of various sizes. Its durable, waterproof design, adjustable settings, and long-range remote make it a valuable tool for dog owners seeking behavioral correction and obedience training. However, careful use and sensitivity to your dog’s needs are crucial for optimal results.

5. Best budget: PATPET Dog Training Collar with Remote

71Xr9I3UTGL. AC SX300

Main Features:

  • Three Training Modes: Beep, Vibration, and 16 adjustable Shock levels
  • Waterproof: Receiver IPX7 waterproof & Remote IPX5 rainproof
  • 3000Ft (1000 yards) Remote Range: Train your dog effectively in long distance
  • Blind Operation Buttons: The remote can be operated by touch without looking at it
  • Suitable for all sizes dogs from 8 to 120 lbs


  • Effective training tool for correcting behavior issues.
  • Versatile sizing for various dog breeds.
  • Durable and waterproof for all-weather use.
  • Long-range remote control for off-leash training.


  • May not be suitable for extremely sensitive dogs.
  • Proper training and supervision are essential to avoid misuse.

Customer Opinions: Our dog is not hurt by this device, When we beep he responds immediately and he does not get upset just pays attention to our demands without being upset. love love it. See More

In conclusion, the PATPET Dog Training Collar with Remote is a powerful tool for dog owners seeking effective training solutions. While it has a few limitations, its numerous benefits make it a worthwhile investment in your pet’s obedience and safety.

How to Use a Dog Training Collar Correctly!

YouTube source

What to Look for When Buying a Training Collar

Dog’s Size and Breed

Ensure the collar you choose is appropriate for your dog’s size and breed. Some collars may not be suitable for smaller or larger dogs, and certain breeds may have specific needs.

Ensure the collar fits your dog comfortably and securely. Measure your dog’s neck to find the right size. Collars that are too tight can cause discomfort, while loose collars may not be effective.

Range and Control

Consider the range of the collar’s remote control. Some collars offer a limited range, while others provide a wider coverage area. Make sure the range suits your training needs.

 Stimulation Levels

Look for a collar with adjustable stimulation levels. Stubborn dogs may require higher levels, but it’s important to start with the lowest effective setting and gradually increase if necessary.

Battery Life

Check the collar’s battery life. Longer battery life means fewer interruptions during training sessions. Some models are rechargeable, while others use replaceable batteries.


Ensure the collar is built to withstand your dog’s activity level. A robust and waterproof design is ideal for dogs that love to play outdoors.

Training Modes

Some collars offer multiple training modes, including tone-only and vibration options. These can be useful for reinforcing commands without using corrective stimulation.

 Safety Features

Look for collars with safety features such as automatic shut-off to prevent overstimulation and a safety lock on the remote to avoid accidental corrections.

User-Friendly Design

Choose a collar that has a remote control that is not just user-friendly but also simple to use even in tense conditions.

Best Training Collar for Stubborn Dogs: FAQs

Why is PATPET better for dogs?

Dog training collar P-Collar 680. PATPET P-Collar 680 Dog Training Collar is the right choice for improving your dog’s behavior at home or in social situations. These safe, compassionate, and effective collars work for all dog kinds and sizes. Adjustable static shock, vibration, and beep settings let you choose a safe mode for your dog’s behavior and demands.

A training collar costs how much?

Dog training collars vary in price and features. Prices vary from $30 to $200 based on the habit or activity you want to teach.

A dog training collar that can withstand the outdoors is essential for hunters and outdoor enthusiasts. A $30 training collar may stop harmful backyard behavior, but it may not withstand hard field conditions. You don’t need to spend a lot to teach a new puppy using a user-friendly model.

What are the best dog shock collars?

Patpet Dog Shock Collar – Best Waterproof The Patpet Dog Shock Collar has a wide range of 1000 feet, so you can easily control the collar from inside your house when your dog is out in the yard. It comes with three training modes, which include static shock, vibration, and beep modes.

How does the stubborn dog collar work?

When your pet reaches the Warning Zone, the Receiver Collar gives a warning beep and vibrates. If your pet continues into the Static Correction Zone, a safe Static Correction will be delivered through the Contact Points to get his attention until he returns to the Pet Area.


In conclusion, finding the best training collar for stubborn dogs requires careful consideration of various factors, including the type of collar, size, range, stimulation levels, battery life, durability, training modes, and safety features. It’s essential to prioritize humane training methods and consult with professionals when necessary.

Remember that effective training goes beyond the collar itself. Consistency, positive reinforcement, and understanding your dog’s specific needs are key to successful training. By following this buying guide and considering these important factors, you can make an informed choice and improve your dog’s behavior effectively and safely.

Related Categories

5/5 - (9 votes)